by Barbara Kingsolver, 2009, HarperCollins Publishers, New York
I was disappointed in the format of this book as it reads as a collection of journal pages, letters, and other assorted excerpts from the life of an individual. Because of this format, the novel lacks the flow of Kingsolver’s previous novels as well as her incredible prose style. Despite these shortcomings, the book has merit … but not the high praise that her other books attract.
The book is the story of Harrison Shepard and his life as told through his journals, letters, and the writings of his close friend and stenographer, Mrs. Violet Brown. The story starts in Mexico where he is living with his mother, a native-born Mexican. The story migrates back to the Washington, D.C., area where he is in boarding school. He then travels back to Mexico where he becomes Leon Trotsky’s cook and secretary and friends of the painters, Diego and Frieda Rivera. He then returns to the U.S. where he writes some very successful novels about the struggles of the Aztecs against the Spanish conquistitor, Cortez.
Shepard is then accused of being a Communist and is summoned to appear in his own defense before the House Un-American Activities Committee.
The novel presents the Red Scare of the early 1950’s in vivid, if somewhat heavy-handed detail. On reading this part of the book, it caused me to ponder the current hysteria targeting socialism. While nobody has been indicted or executed for his or her socialist viewpoints and the hysteria is evidenced primarily by the party that is out of power, the level of acrimony seems to be rising. Could we, perhaps, be on our way back to the mentality of the 50’s?
While this book is not as enjoyable to read as her previous novels were, it is, nevertheless, worthwhile if you can stick with it.